Extreme Lower Back Pain with antalgic posture and unable to turn in bed

by Kerry
(Pembroke Pines, FL, USA)

Where does it hurt if someone lifts your leg? Slump test.

Where does it hurt if someone lifts your leg? Slump test.

Extreme Lower Back Pain with antalgic posture and unable to turn in bed requires very careful management; an MRI will help identify the level involved.

I have been having lower back pain for a few weeks now that seem to get progressively worse. I sleep with 2 pillows under my feet but when I stand, I have the antalgic posture which I try to straighten by the method of the Mackenzie wall press. However, walking for a bit starts the pain in my buttock region and if I sit to drive or sit for any amount of time, I get pain in my calf and thigh; it's not a linear pain but the pain would be in the buttock and then felt in the left calf or buttock, left calf & lower back of thigh region. It becomes extremely difficult to get out the car after sitting for any time.

Also, while laying in bed, I find it extremely difficult to turn from either laying on my back to one of my sides or vice versa. I stayed home for a week but had many doctors appointment including 2 visits with the Chiropractor that didn't help. I've seen the Chiropractor for 2 weeks now at a rate of twice a week with no help.

I've been doing the Mackenzie stretches which helped in my pain but I know more needs to be done. I return to work on Monday & I am terrified as I sit at a computer all day & I know the pain I will be in will be unbearable.

I find that the pain is concentrated right now in the buttock region, to me around the SI joint but it could just be a false disposition though I find if I can relieve that area, I'm in less pain which I can tolerate. Unfortunately, my doctors have not prescribed any medication for me as I recently found it I was pregnant. I'm not planning to carry the child to term especially with the amount of pain I'm in.

I just want to know what else can I do at home to relieve pain so I can sit for a bit & walk. I found my Chiropractor unhelpful as the progress I've made so far was due to lumbar herniated disc exercises suggested by YT PT. Any help is greatly appreciated. Thank you.

Dear Kerry,
You're between a rock and a hard place; the management of an antalgia is complex and if not correctly done, leads progressively to hard neurological signs; loss of reflex, numbness and an inability to raise the big toe, or raise your heel. Watch for these signs.

Then if you continue with your normal life, surgery is imminent.

Frankly most of the painkillers don't touch this acute pain anyway. Let alternating ice and warmth be your friend. Don't sit; if you do the chances of surgery increase dramatically. Don't go to work until the antalgia is resolved; alternating lying down, with gentle back exercises, and arising every hour for as long as you can manage to go to the loo, make tea; no housework.

Chiropractic manipulation is an art learned the hard way; and along with it, if you are sitting and bending, and continuing largely with your normal life, cannot succeed. There's a large hole in your disc through which the gel has bulged; anything that increases the pressure in the disc, such as sitting, means that even after a very successful manipulation, the nucleus will slowly leak through again.

I don't know the ins and outs of your case obviously, but I personally would have treated you more frequently, and wouldn't have allowed you to drive to consultations.

You have obviously lost confidence in the chiropractor you have been consulting; antalgias are tough and frankly none of us wins all the time; I don't. One good sneeze can change everything.

One of the great difficulties is that the level is not always clear; most likely it's at L4/L5 or L5/S1; higher would affect the femoral nerve. You can even have a hernia at two levels making treatment and management yet more difficult.

Since you are not getting better, insist now on an MRI; it will resolve many of these conundrums and is safe in pregnancy. Then start asking around for the name of a more skilled and experienced chiropractor.

Accept now, whether you go for surgery, chiropractic or some other form of treatment that simple, gentle back exercises done every morning for the rest of your life are your lot; it will come back even after the most successful treatment and how soon depends on whether you do those exercises and use constraint when it comes to bending and lifting.

I have treated thousands of cases like yours, and in fact personally had an even more serious injury myself; they are resolvable but it takes skill, restraint on your part and a high level of trust between doctor and patient.

There's no need to abort your baby.

Have a look at our slipped disc rules.

I hope this contributes.

Dr B

» Extreme Lower Back Pain with antalgic posture and unable to turn in bed

Click here to post comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Chiropractic help Questions (Low back pain).

Did you find this page useful? Then perhaps forward it to a suffering friend. Better still, Tweet or Face Book it.

Share this page:
Enjoy this page? Then forward it to a friend. Here's how...

Would you prefer to share this page with others by linking to it?

  1. Click on the HTML link code below.
  2. Copy and paste it, adding a note of your own, into your blog, a Web page, forums, a blog comment, your Facebook account, or anywhere that someone would find this page valuable.