Chiropractor cracked my ribs. Is this a mistake what she did?

by Neil
(Houston, Texas)

Kefir is a good natural solution to osteoporosis

Kefir is a good natural solution to osteoporosis

I have piriformis syndrome. I saw a Chiropractor yesterday. As I was laying on my stomach she pushed down on my back but, not in the center. When she pushed down, I heard a crunching sound on my right rib cage which really hurt.

After a couple of minutes, the pain went away but, today, my ribs still hurt with bearable pain.

Did she mess up or, is this normal?

Thank you so much.

Hello Neil,
No, it's certainly not normal, but I won't pretend that it's very rare. I'm a careful adjuster and I confess to eight patients in forty years who have had this experience at my hands.

It's probably not a cracked rib as then the pain would by unbearable; every breath would be a nightmare. Nevertheless, clearly there was some damage to the integrity of the bone.

A cracked rib is to a chiropractor what a broken root is to a dentist, and an allergic reaction to penicillin is to a medical doctor. If people sued us every time it happened there would be no more doctors of any ilk on the planet.

It's important to talk frankly to your chiropractor about this; she must stay off the area until it heals and then perhaps only use an activator when adjusting the ribs. Treatment for the piriformis can continue but she will have to adjust her techniques; hopefully she eats humble pie; it's never nice to know you have hurt a patient, but it happens; once in five years in my practice, but every one hurt me as much and perhaps more than the patient.

One last thought; this is unusual in a male. Mostly it happens to elderly women. An investigation into the possibility of brittle bone disease would not be inappropriate; could there be an underlying parathyroid deficiency, for example. In any event, I'd give thought to best calcium for osteoporosis; from your food; in tablet form it raises the incidence of heart disease because of deposition in the coronary arteries. See our osteoporosis page in the navigation bar on your left. Enjoying kefir benefits every morning for breakfast would be a simple beginning, and improve the health of your colon at the same time; it's a probiotic.

It will probably be quite sore for about two weeks; pray you don't get a cold! A sneeze or cough would be a nightmare; blowing your nose timeously will often preempt it. There will be no sequela; you will recover completely.

Please let me know in two or three weeks how you are doing; thank you for your query.

Dr B

Comments for Chiropractor cracked my ribs. Is this a mistake what she did?

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Dec 04, 2019
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Back cracked after leaning over
by: Dominic

I went to a chiropractor today. He adjusted the centre of my back, then I felt my ribs cracked and I could not breathe for about 15 seconds.

He asked me to get up and after a few seconds, I felt fine. No pain, no soreness and my back pain was gone.

An hour later I went to lean over, my back cracked and I felt sharp pain in my ribs. I feel fine now but I am getting scared. Do you have any advice?

Hello Dominic,
Apologies for the delay in answering your question.

Some immediate discomfort and even pain after a chiropractic adjustment is not uncommon. The fact you felt so much better and had no pain after a few seconds certainly confirm that he had not cracked a rib.

Almost every chiropractor has cracked a few ribs, and I will admit to my share; one every four years on average. It is self-limiting and the patient recovers completely. This was not your problem.

After an adjustment the spine is vulnerable for a period; the muscles and ligaments have been loosened and a setback is not uncommon. For some people with a weak back this really can apply for a few days. Be careful after the treatment.

You were lucky and despite the pain an hour later, you recovered with no further treatment; that is a tribute to your general condition.

You do not have to be unduly anxious after a chiropractic adjustment, but an degree of common sense is needed; that is not the time to lift the grand piano.

Talk to your chiropractor about your doubts; an honest relationship is important.

I hope this contributes.

Dr B.R. Lewis DC

Dec 04, 2019
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Same thing
by: DJ

I went to a chiropractor today. He cracked the center of my back, then I felt my ribs cracked and I could not breath for about 15 seconds. He asked me to get up and after a few seconds, I felt fine. No pain, no sourness and my back pain was gone. An hour later I went to lean over, my back cracked and I felt sharp pain in my ribs. I feel fine now but I'm getting scared. Any advice?

Jun 01, 2019
Rating
starstarstar
chiropractor badly bruised my ribs on first visit by cracking my back... no heated packs first!
by: Mama

I’m in so much pain.... left his office a message to see if he could give me a RX to get chest X-rays but he was only in his far away office. So I had to drive myself to ER. They said I had Contusions in my ribs on right side under chest. So much pain... Doc text me twice saying he was sorry I got hurt but never called to talk to me! That was upsetting! Here it is over a week later & I'm in more pain than when it happened... wondering if I should get an MRI to get a better look; plus now I have some kind of respiratory infection complete with fever; think I got it from shallow breathing avoiding more pain. Ugh. I give up... go to a doc to get help with headaches & neck pain... leave with bruised ribs & no phone call at all! 😠

You've every right to be grumpy, Mama. Firstly that you were hurt and secondly that he didn't even bother to phone. I'm sure you won't, but don't go back.

The good news is that a contused rib, even a cracked rib will heal; it's usually painful for about two weeks. An MRI really won't contribute much.

Nasty that you have a fever, and coughing will certainly be very painful and even slow healing. See your doctor for some medication, even though it's probably viral and antibiotics won't help much. At least get some advice.

I'm afraid there isn't a chiropractor about who hasn't cracked a rib or two, including yours truly! It is self limiting. What's upsetting is his uncaring attitude. Inexcusable.

Be strong, you'll get over this, but it certainly is miserable for a couple weeks. An ice pack over the site of the injury will help.

Let us know how you get on.

Dr B

Jun 19, 2018
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
reply in 3 weeks
by: Neil

Bone density and heart attack!?

Now you are scaring me!

I know you are trying to help and educate me.

I will come back in 3 weeks to let you know how I am doing.

GOD bless you for your reply and help.

Thank you so much.


My pleasure, Neil, that's what this site is about.

Dr B



Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to LOVE HATE.





Did you find this page useful? Then perhaps forward it to a suffering friend. Better still, Tweet or Face Book it.