Pain in upper leg

Case File @ Chiropractic Help

Keywords; pain in upper leg, femoro acetabular impingement, Maignes syndrome.

Mrs V, a  63 year old woman has had left LBP for about ten years. There was no obvious cause. Twelve months before her first consultation severe pain began in the left groin, radiating down the front of the thigh towards the knee. Periodically her upper leg would suddenly give, partly with a sharp stab, and also due to a weak feeling.

Frequently she could barely walk, the ache in her upper left leg was so bad.

She wore a heel lift in her right shoe; that brought some measure of relief.

Treatment by an orthopaedic surgeon specialised in manipulation brought some relief of pain, and especially the insert in her shoe, but her leg continued to buckle under her, and walking remained very difficult. After several months, this doctor referred her to our clinic for evaluation.

On examination, bare foot, it was clear that she had a very short right leg, a sharply tilted pelvis, low on the right, and an accompanying scoliosis, convex right; or, was it left? Was I going crazy? The xrays told a completely different story.

Ranges of motion of the lumbar spine were good, without radiation of pain to the leg, or significant pain in the back.

Left hip: Flexion and internal and external rotation were full, and without pain; thus, no hip arthritis. However, adduction, pulling the knee towards the opposite shoulder caused sharp pain in the groin.

The test called Patrick's Faber test, was also strongly painful and some movements were limited in the groin. Hip arthritis? Femoro Acetabular Impingement Syndrome?

Most odd, was that the Slump test provoked pain in the front of the  thigh - it's a test for the Sciatic nerve which, when pinched or irritated, would cause pain down the back of the leg. In that sense, the Slump test for sciatica was negative.

However, the Femoral nerve stretch test was positive, with pain in the front of the left thigh. A pinched nerve, either in the groin or lumbar spine? Upper leg pain always calls for careful examination. 

Pain in upper leg

Neurological examination of pain in upper leg

Once again there were contradictory results: The reflexes were normal and there were no sensory changes, but the Quadriceps muscle was weak - the probably the cause of her leg suddenly giving under her weight, particularly on the stairs. Unusual with a normal reflex.

Chiropractic Help examination

She stood very prominently with a short RIGHT leg, and attendant scoliosis. There were fixations in the right sacroiliac joint anatomy, and at the L1 joint.

With groin and pain in upper leg (front of leg), the involement of the Femoral nerve and a possible Maignes syndrome was high in my list of differential diagnoses of upper leg pain. Sacroiliac joint anatomy ...


There's no mention whether this X-ray of the pelvis was taken standing, or lying supine. That's important when making decisions about a heel lift. The strong implication here was very short LEFT leg.

Was I going crazy? I have got it wrong before, and sometimes an apparent short leg can change after treatment of the pelvis. So, a phone call to the hospital. Indeed, the radiograph was taken lying supine. It was just a bad set-up by the radiographer.


This whole case is loaded with difficulties.

  1. Severe pain in upper leg, lasting a whole year, despite various medical treatments is obviously a serious concern.
  2. The X-ray report of the hips was "normal". But she had severe pain in the hip - in the groin.
  3. No recent X-rays of her back were available.
  4. Physical examination by both the orthopaedic specialist, and myself, confirmed a short RIGHT leg. But the X-ray of the pelvis suggested a very short LEFT leg.
  5. Any condition that causes "hard neurological signs" - altered reflexes or sensation, or weakness, are serious.
  6. But weakness in the large thigh muscle, the Quadriceps, with no change in the knee jerk reflex? That makes no sense. Diabetes mellitus?

Chiropractic Help

Following the Thompson drop protocol we adjusted the sacrum on the right, L1 on the left with the so-called "million dollar" roll.

The left hip was mobilised and the Adductor magnus, pectineus and psoas with treated with the Active Release Technique (extremely painful).

A vigorous rehab programme is always part of chiropractic help for any chronic condition.


Mrs V consulted me again today. She comes with her husband once every six weeks.

She's a very happy lady, but I'm still confused. She can walk long distances without her leg collapsing under her, and without pain in her thigh. But I still don't confidently have the correct diagnosis. Many years ago I learnt an important lesson from Dr Glynn Till, president (now retired) of the Chiropractic College in Durban, South Africa.

"Remember, the patient may have two different conditions."

Dr G. Till, DC

Femoro Acetabular Impingement syndrome

The spot xray of her left hip reveals little arthritis superiorally to speak of, mild signs of Femoro Acetabular Impingement Syndrome Pincer and CAM, and several unnoticed cystic lesion in the ball of the femur.

It's time for new xrays and, depending on the result, an MRI. Those of her lumbar spine, taken standing with the heel lift in place in the right shoe, and a new spot of the left hip; and a test for diabetes.

That diabetes test is just routine. I'm not expecting it to be positive. She is not obese, there is no urinary frequency, no loss of weight, no abnormal thirst and, when a diabetic neuropathy causes weakness in the quadriceps muscle, there's no pain in the upper leg usually; it's silent and deadly.

Like all case files, this is in development, and will always remain so. She thinks the future is rosy, but I have unanswered questions. Meantime, she walks, she does her back and pelvis rehabilitation exercises, and she's happy. They are off hiking in the Black Forest in the south of Germany this week; life is full.

Three years later, I've just had the good fortune to see her whilst doing a locum in the Netherlands; she continues to do fantastically well, coming in every six to eight weeks for maintenance care. 

Here is another difficult pain in upper leg file. 

Mrs S came for treatment for terrible headaches. An elderly woman, I was shocked at how many analgesics she was taking. Rebound headache is actually caused by taking bucketfuls of pills.

There was nothing simple about her upper neck headaches, but they have now stabilised at about 80 percent better and she needs little medication.

The problem is that she is always very sore for about three days after an adjustment. So now she comes once in two months, and is very happy.

But her upper leg?

After an operation to remove a sickly ovary she developed severe pain in the groin and upper thigh. I suspected they knicked a branch of the femoral nerve and there was little to be done. But she did have a L2 fixation; the femoral nerve comes from the upper lumbar spine.

As with her neck, she was very sore in her lower back for three days, but hey presto, no more restless legs at night, no more hanging the leg outside the blankets, no more pain. And she does her lumbar exercises very faithfully.


 Health is additive. The positives and the negatives. This lady has been has heavy as 160kg, now 117kg has a double spondylolysthesis (old trauma most likely), has Femero Acetabular Impingement Syndrome and severely arthritic knees. An interesting case: Pain and tingling in feet and legs Casefile...

Useful links @ Pain in upper leg

Groin and/or thigh pain?

Do you have a question about leg pain? Share it!

[ ? ]

Upload 1-4 Pictures or Graphics (optional)[ ? ]


Click here to upload more images (optional)

Author Information (optional)

To receive credit as the author, enter your information below.

(first or full name)

(e.g., City, State, Country)

Submit Your Contribution

 submission guidelines.

(You can preview and edit on the next page)

What Other Visitors Have Said

Click below to see contributions from other visitors to this page...

Another case of undiagnosed hip dysplasia 
Hi all- I was diagnosed with dysplasia at 38 after a couple of years of weakness and a "weird unstable feeling". The ortho did not mention Peri Acetabular …

pain across side and front of thigh 
Pain across side and front of thigh I started walking and exercising a year ago. I was then and am now 200 pounds and sedentary. I got up to walking …

Female 49 years old with lower back and buttock pain possibly sciatica and femoral nerve pain. Not rated yet
I am 49 yr. old female. I have an ache and pressure in my right buttock and an intermittent sharp and sometimes sudden quick pain in my groin and hip. …

pinched nerve around inguinal ligament Not rated yet
At the junction of my thigh and and my right lower abdomen I get a pinch as I rotate my leg to the outside and pain comes when I try to bring my leg to …

Meralgia Paresthetica treatments Not rated yet
My son has developed this condition 3 months a go with pain and weakness in left thigh and sensitive in lateral thigh and less in anterior thigh. Has severe …

upper left groin pain difficulty supporting weight for walking Not rated yet
sharp pain in upper left groin area. right side not so bad. took a fall 12 ft 3 days ago. Broke my wrist and 4 ribs now the pain in the groin can only …

Lower right abdominal pain - groin and hip area. Not rated yet
I had a suspected appendicitis 10 months ago with bleeding in bowel. No cause has been found despite extensive investigations (CT, MRI, Ultrasound). Findings …

Click here to write your own.

Did you find this page useful? Then perhaps forward it to a suffering friend. Better still, Tweet or Face Book it.

Interesting challenges of the day

1. Mrs B has had one of the nastiest of conditions; vertigo caused by a disturbance in the inner ear. Falling repeatedly and vomiting she consulted her doctor but medication didn't help. After two sessions of the Epley manoeuvres she was 50 percent better. After two weeks she was 75 percent improved; no longer vomiting or falling. She's not enjoying the Brandt Daroff home exercises.

2. Mr S, a 48 year old man, has right low back pain, groin pain and a numb feeling in his lower leg when he sports. For six months he's been off football. He too has two problems; a very treatable lumbar facet syndrome and a very serious blocked artery in the groin; it's called intermittent claudication. Smokers beware.  

3. Mr S looks like the leaning tower of Pisa; he has a slipped disc at L5 making him lean towards the opposite side. It's called the postero lateral disc hernia; we'll fix it, but he has to stop for a week or two. Antalgias are serious so take them seriously. 

4. Mrs V too has two conditions; a chronic low grade sciatica giving her an ache in the right leg, and a threatening Morton's neuroma. She's glad I'm back in Holland; chiropractic fixed it before, and we'll fix it again. 

5. Mrs W is one of the lucky ones, says her doctor. I agree. He says only 40% of patients with lumbar stenosis have a successful operation. We fixed a nasty slipped disc three years ago, but it came back two years later; the surgeon did a fine job but she has a weak ankle now giving her subtalar joint pain; it's routine stuff. 

6. I myself had an acute exacerbation of a femoral nerve lesion last year. One immediate treatment of the new strain by my colleague has fixed the pain in the lower back, but there's some residual numbness in the lower leg; no soaring tomorrow alas.

7. This lady is a 86 year old woman with a 63 scoliosis. Chronic lower back has been her lot in life but she's well pleased with chiropractic and comes for chiropractic help once a month; some conditions you can never cure.

8. She is an 78 year old woman, is doing remarkably well with a bad sciatica. But over 200 pounds she is not losing weight; in fact, gaining despite my suggestions. She's high risk for a stroke. I have referred her to a dietician to crack the whip.

9. A 61 year old man with upper cervical pain yesterday; it's not severe but also not getting better of its own accord. He's afraid it may turn very acute as when I treated him three years ago. Since then it's been fine. 

10. A 64 year old woman has had scheuermanns disease; it's left her with a spinal kyphosis and chronic middorsal pain. She responds well to chiropractic treatment provides she come every six weeks or so for maintenance treatment.

11. Mrs C has been having severe headaches, and taking a lot of analgesics. It's a non complicated upper cervical facet syndrome, and she's doing well.

12. Mrs D, a middle aged woman with hip pain of one year duration, despite other treatment. Xrays reveal an impingement syndrome and early hip arthritis. There's much to be done.

13. Mr D, a 71 year old man, has a severe ache in the shoulder and midback since working above his head. Trapped nerve tests are negative but he has advanced degenerative joints of Luschka; after just two treatments he is 50 percent better. Can we reach 90?

And so the day goes; chiropractors shouldn't be treating the elderly most medical sites state but that's so much bunkum.

Have a problem that's not getting better? Looking for a different slant on your pain? Want to pose a question?

Interesting questions from visitors

CLS writes:

Greetings, Dr B.
You helped me quite some time back with a soothing and professional response which turned out to be exactly correct. I now consult a local chiropractor. You write a superb newsletter, too.

Your own unresolved problem. Pose a question

Knowing that up to 70% of the time the correct diagnosis is made with no examination, no special tests, no xrays, but just from the history, there's a fair chance I can add some insight to your unresolved problem. But at least 30% of the time, I may be quite wrong! Give plenty of detail if you want a sensible reply.

You visited this chiropractic help site no doubt because you have a problem that is not resolving and want to know more about what chiropractors do.

The quickest and most interesting way is to read one of my ebooks of anecdotes. Described by a reader as gems, both funny and healthful, from the life and work of a chiropractor, you'll love them. Priced right at $2.99, though Kindle fiddles the price without telling me.